, Woo Cheal Cho2
1Department of Pathology and Immunology, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX, USA
2Department of Anatomical Pathology, The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, TX, USA
© The Korean Society of Pathologists/The Korean Society for Cytopathology
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Ethics Statement
All procedures performed in the current review were approved by the IRB of the University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center (IRB#: 2022-0662) in accordance with the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments. Formal written informed consent was not required with a waiver by the appropriate IRB.
Availability of Data and Material
The data of this review are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Code Availability
Not applicable.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization: WCC. Data curation: MHA. Formal analysis: MHA. Funding acquisition: WCC. Investigation: all authors. Methodology: WCC. Project administration: WCC. Resources: WCC. Software: N/A. Supervision: WCC. Validation: all authors. Visualization: all authors. Writing—original draft preparation: all authors. Writing—review & editing: all authors. Approval of final manuscript: all authors.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare that they have no potential conflicts of interest.
Funding
This review was supported in part by the Institutional Start-up Funds from the University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center awarded to WCC.
| Category | Type | TRPS1 expression patterns | Potential diagnostic utility and other key points |
|---|---|---|---|
| Normal skin | Eccrine glands, acrosyringia, matrical cells, mesenchymal cells of dermal papillae [2,6] | Strong (3+) | Serve as ideal internal controls |
| Anogenital mammary-like glands [9] | Strong (3+) | - | |
| Sebocytes of sebaceous glands [2,6] | Weak-to-moderate (1+ to 2+) | - | |
| Outer and inner root sheaths of hair follicles [2,6] | Weak-to-strong (1+ to 3+) | - | |
| Epidermal keratinocytes in stratum spinosum [2,6] | Weak-to-moderate (1+ to 2+) | - | |
| Epidermal keratinocytes in stratum basale [2,6] | Negative | May explain the frequent absence of TRPS1 expression in basal cell carcinomas | |
| Apocrine glands [2,6] | Negative | - | |
| Non-adnexal epithelial neoplasms | Squamous cell carcinoma [2,6] | Moderate-to-strong (2+ to 3+); patchy-to-diffuse | May provide potential diagnostic utility in distinguishing squamous cell carcinomas from basal cell carcinomas |
| Basal cell carcinoma [5,6] | Negative (typically); only focal when present | May provide potential diagnostic utility in distinguishing basal cell carcinomas from squamous cell carcinomas | |
| Merkel cell carcinoma [5,6] | Negative | Helps distinguish Merkel cell carcinomas (TRPS1–/INSM1+) from endocrine mucin-producing sweat gland carcinomas (TRPS1+/INSM1+) | |
| Adnexal neoplasms with apocrine and eccrine differentiation | Endocrine mucin-producing sweat gland carcinoma [5,6] | Strong (3+); diffuse | Helps distinguish endocrine mucin-producing sweat gland carcinomas (TRPS1+/INSM1+) from basal cell carcinomas (TRPS1–/INSM1–) and Merkel cell carcinomas (TRPS1–/INSM1+) |
| Primary cutaneous NUT adnexal carcinoma [15,16] | Strong (3+); diffuse | Helps distinguish primary cutaneous NUT adnexal carcinomas (TRPS1+/SOX10+/NUT+) from basal cell carcinomas (TRPS1–/SOX10–/NUT–) | |
| Benign (poroma, hidradenoma, spiradenoma, cylindroma, syringoma, syringocystadenoma papilliferum) | Weak-to-strong (1+ to 3+); focal-to-diffuse | Lacks diagnostic utility in distinguishing these tumor types from their morphologic mimics | |
| Malignant (porocarcinoma, hidradenocarcinoma, digital papillary adenocarcinoma, squamoid eccrine ductal carcinoma) [5-7,9,10,15,16] | Weak-to-strong (1+ to 3+); focal-to-diffuse | Lacks diagnostic utility in distinguishing these tumor types from their morphologic mimics | |
| Primary cutaneous apocrine carcinoma [11,17] | Negative (typically) | Diffuse expression reported in one rare case with a RARA::NPEPPS fusion [11] | |
| Microcystic adnexal carcinoma [7] | Negative | - | |
| Adnexal neoplasms with follicular differentiation | Benign (trichoepithelioma, trichoblastoma, trichilemmoma, trichofolliculoma, pilar sheath acanthoma, proliferating pilar tumor, pilometricoma) | Weak-to-strong (1+ to 3+); focal-to-diffuse | Largely lacks diagnostic utility in distinguishing these tumor types from their morphologic mimics |
| Malignant (malignant proliferating trichilemmal tumor, trichilemmal carcinoma, trichoblastic carcinoma) [6,8,9] | Weak-to-strong (1+ to 3+); focal-to-diffuse | May be useful to highlight the papillary mesenchymal bodies of trichoepitheliomas and trichoblastomas, which exhibit strong (3+) TRPS1 expression | |
| Adnexal neoplasms with sebaceous differentiation | Sebaceous adenoma, sebaceoma, sebaceous carcinoma [6,9] | Weak-to-moderate (1+ to 2+); focal-to-diffuse | Lacks diagnostic utility in distinguishing sebaceous adenomas from sebaceous carcinomas |
| Site-specific adnexal neoplasms | Mammary Paget disease [2-4,9] | Strong (3+); diffuse | Helps distinguish mammary Paget diseases (TRPS1+/p63–/SOX10–) from melanomas in situ (TRPS1–/p63–/SOX10+) and pagetoid squamous cell carcinomas in situ (TRPS1+/p63+/SOX10–) |
| Primary extramammary Paget disease arising in non-perianal cutaneous sites [2-4,9] | Strong (3+); diffuse | Helps distinguish primary extramammary Paget diseases (TRPS1+/p63–/SOX10–) from melanomas in situ (TRPS1–/p63–/SOX10+) and pagetoid squamous cell carcinomas in situ (TRPS1+/p63+/SOX10–) | |
| The presence of TRPS1 expression is highly sensitive (100%) and specific (100%) for primary extramammary Paget disease of non-perianal cutaneous origin and essentially rules out secondary extramammary Paget disease | |||
| Primary extramammary Paget disease arising in the perianal region [2-4,9] | Negative (typically) | The immunoprofile (TRPS1–) mimics that of secondary extramammary Paget disease (TRPS1–), invariably requiring additional clinical workup (e.g., endoscopy, imaging studies) to completely rule out an internal malignancy | |
| Secondary extramammary Paget disease [2-4,9] | Negative | The lack of TRPS1 expression strongly supports a diagnosis of secondary extramammary Paget disease over primary extramammary Paget disease, except for lesions arising in the perianal region | |
| Hidradenoma papilliferum [13] | Strong (3+); diffuse | - | |
| Melanocytic neoplasms | Melanoma situ and invasive melanoma [1,2] | Negative | Helps distinguish melanomas in situ (TRPS1–/SOX10+) from mammary and extramammary Paget diseases (TRPS1+/SOX10–), including mammary Paget diseases secondary to underlying triple-negative breast carcinomas, which can be positive for SOX10 (TRPS1+/SOX10+) [18,19] |
| Mesenchymal neoplasms | Atypical fibroxanthoma/pleomorphic dermal sarcoma, angiosarcoma, dermatofibroma, dermatofibrosarcoma protuberans, Kaposi sarcoma, leiomyoma, leiomyosarcoma, neurofibroma, malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumor [12,20] | Weak-to-strong (1+ to 3+); focal-to-diffuse | Lacks diagnostic utility in distinguishing these tumor types from their morphologic mimics |
| Atypical fibroxanthomas/pleomorphic dermal sarcomas exhibit the highest median H-score of 240, while vascular neoplasms and peripheral nerve sheath tumors consistently show low median H-scores below 10 [12] | |||
| Schwannoma [20] | Negative | - | |
| Cutaneous metastatic carcinomas | Carcinoma of mammary origin [1,9,14] | Strong (3+); diffuse | The presence of strong and diffuse TRPS1 expression helps support a diagnosis of metastatic carcinoma of mammary origin in the appropriate morphologic and immunophenotypic (CK7+/GATA3+) context |
| Carcinomas of pulmonary, gynecological, or renal origin [9,14] | Weak (1+); focal (occasionally) | - | |
| Carcinomas of gastrointestinal or prostatic origin [9,14] | Negative | - |
| Category | Type | TRPS1 expression patterns | Potential diagnostic utility and other key points |
|---|---|---|---|
| Normal skin | Eccrine glands, acrosyringia, matrical cells, mesenchymal cells of dermal papillae [2,6] | Strong (3+) | Serve as ideal internal controls |
| Anogenital mammary-like glands [9] | Strong (3+) | - | |
| Sebocytes of sebaceous glands [2,6] | Weak-to-moderate (1+ to 2+) | - | |
| Outer and inner root sheaths of hair follicles [2,6] | Weak-to-strong (1+ to 3+) | - | |
| Epidermal keratinocytes in stratum spinosum [2,6] | Weak-to-moderate (1+ to 2+) | - | |
| Epidermal keratinocytes in stratum basale [2,6] | Negative | May explain the frequent absence of TRPS1 expression in basal cell carcinomas | |
| Apocrine glands [2,6] | Negative | - | |
| Non-adnexal epithelial neoplasms | Squamous cell carcinoma [2,6] | Moderate-to-strong (2+ to 3+); patchy-to-diffuse | May provide potential diagnostic utility in distinguishing squamous cell carcinomas from basal cell carcinomas |
| Basal cell carcinoma [5,6] | Negative (typically); only focal when present | May provide potential diagnostic utility in distinguishing basal cell carcinomas from squamous cell carcinomas | |
| Merkel cell carcinoma [5,6] | Negative | Helps distinguish Merkel cell carcinomas (TRPS1–/INSM1+) from endocrine mucin-producing sweat gland carcinomas (TRPS1+/INSM1+) | |
| Adnexal neoplasms with apocrine and eccrine differentiation | Endocrine mucin-producing sweat gland carcinoma [5,6] | Strong (3+); diffuse | Helps distinguish endocrine mucin-producing sweat gland carcinomas (TRPS1+/INSM1+) from basal cell carcinomas (TRPS1–/INSM1–) and Merkel cell carcinomas (TRPS1–/INSM1+) |
| Primary cutaneous NUT adnexal carcinoma [15,16] | Strong (3+); diffuse | Helps distinguish primary cutaneous NUT adnexal carcinomas (TRPS1+/SOX10+/NUT+) from basal cell carcinomas (TRPS1–/SOX10–/NUT–) | |
| Benign (poroma, hidradenoma, spiradenoma, cylindroma, syringoma, syringocystadenoma papilliferum) | Weak-to-strong (1+ to 3+); focal-to-diffuse | Lacks diagnostic utility in distinguishing these tumor types from their morphologic mimics | |
| Malignant (porocarcinoma, hidradenocarcinoma, digital papillary adenocarcinoma, squamoid eccrine ductal carcinoma) [5-7,9,10,15,16] | Weak-to-strong (1+ to 3+); focal-to-diffuse | Lacks diagnostic utility in distinguishing these tumor types from their morphologic mimics | |
| Primary cutaneous apocrine carcinoma [11,17] | Negative (typically) | Diffuse expression reported in one rare case with a RARA::NPEPPS fusion [11] | |
| Microcystic adnexal carcinoma [7] | Negative | - | |
| Adnexal neoplasms with follicular differentiation | Benign (trichoepithelioma, trichoblastoma, trichilemmoma, trichofolliculoma, pilar sheath acanthoma, proliferating pilar tumor, pilometricoma) | Weak-to-strong (1+ to 3+); focal-to-diffuse | Largely lacks diagnostic utility in distinguishing these tumor types from their morphologic mimics |
| Malignant (malignant proliferating trichilemmal tumor, trichilemmal carcinoma, trichoblastic carcinoma) [6,8,9] | Weak-to-strong (1+ to 3+); focal-to-diffuse | May be useful to highlight the papillary mesenchymal bodies of trichoepitheliomas and trichoblastomas, which exhibit strong (3+) TRPS1 expression | |
| Adnexal neoplasms with sebaceous differentiation | Sebaceous adenoma, sebaceoma, sebaceous carcinoma [6,9] | Weak-to-moderate (1+ to 2+); focal-to-diffuse | Lacks diagnostic utility in distinguishing sebaceous adenomas from sebaceous carcinomas |
| Site-specific adnexal neoplasms | Mammary Paget disease [2-4,9] | Strong (3+); diffuse | Helps distinguish mammary Paget diseases (TRPS1+/p63–/SOX10–) from melanomas in situ (TRPS1–/p63–/SOX10+) and pagetoid squamous cell carcinomas in situ (TRPS1+/p63+/SOX10–) |
| Primary extramammary Paget disease arising in non-perianal cutaneous sites [2-4,9] | Strong (3+); diffuse | Helps distinguish primary extramammary Paget diseases (TRPS1+/p63–/SOX10–) from melanomas in situ (TRPS1–/p63–/SOX10+) and pagetoid squamous cell carcinomas in situ (TRPS1+/p63+/SOX10–) | |
| The presence of TRPS1 expression is highly sensitive (100%) and specific (100%) for primary extramammary Paget disease of non-perianal cutaneous origin and essentially rules out secondary extramammary Paget disease | |||
| Primary extramammary Paget disease arising in the perianal region [2-4,9] | Negative (typically) | The immunoprofile (TRPS1–) mimics that of secondary extramammary Paget disease (TRPS1–), invariably requiring additional clinical workup (e.g., endoscopy, imaging studies) to completely rule out an internal malignancy | |
| Secondary extramammary Paget disease [2-4,9] | Negative | The lack of TRPS1 expression strongly supports a diagnosis of secondary extramammary Paget disease over primary extramammary Paget disease, except for lesions arising in the perianal region | |
| Hidradenoma papilliferum [13] | Strong (3+); diffuse | - | |
| Melanocytic neoplasms | Melanoma situ and invasive melanoma [1,2] | Negative | Helps distinguish melanomas in situ (TRPS1–/SOX10+) from mammary and extramammary Paget diseases (TRPS1+/SOX10–), including mammary Paget diseases secondary to underlying triple-negative breast carcinomas, which can be positive for SOX10 (TRPS1+/SOX10+) [18,19] |
| Mesenchymal neoplasms | Atypical fibroxanthoma/pleomorphic dermal sarcoma, angiosarcoma, dermatofibroma, dermatofibrosarcoma protuberans, Kaposi sarcoma, leiomyoma, leiomyosarcoma, neurofibroma, malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumor [12,20] | Weak-to-strong (1+ to 3+); focal-to-diffuse | Lacks diagnostic utility in distinguishing these tumor types from their morphologic mimics |
| Atypical fibroxanthomas/pleomorphic dermal sarcomas exhibit the highest median H-score of 240, while vascular neoplasms and peripheral nerve sheath tumors consistently show low median H-scores below 10 [12] | |||
| Schwannoma [20] | Negative | - | |
| Cutaneous metastatic carcinomas | Carcinoma of mammary origin [1,9,14] | Strong (3+); diffuse | The presence of strong and diffuse TRPS1 expression helps support a diagnosis of metastatic carcinoma of mammary origin in the appropriate morphologic and immunophenotypic (CK7+/GATA3+) context |
| Carcinomas of pulmonary, gynecological, or renal origin [9,14] | Weak (1+); focal (occasionally) | - | |
| Carcinomas of gastrointestinal or prostatic origin [9,14] | Negative | - |
TRPS1, trichorhinophalangeal syndrome type 1; INSM1, insulinoma-associated protein 1; CK, cytokeratin.