The Interobserver Variability for Diagnosing Pulmonary Carcinoid Tumor.

Chang Hun Lee; Hee Kyung Chang; Hyoun Wook Lee; Dong Hoon Shin; Mee Sook Roh

doi:10.4132/KoreanJPathol.2010.44.3.267

Articles

Page Path: HOME > J Pathol Transl Med > Volume 44(3); 2010 > Article

Original Article The Interobserver Variability for Diagnosing Pulmonary Carcinoid Tumor.: Chang Hun Lee, Hee Kyung Chang, Hyoun Wook Lee, Dong Hoon Shin, Mee Sook Roh; Journal of Pathology and Translational Medicine 2010;44(3):267-271
DOI: https://doi.org/10.4132/KoreanJPathol.2010.44.3.267

¹Department of Pathology, Pusan National University College of Medicine, Busan, Korea.
²Department of Pathology, Kosin University College of Medicine, Busan, Korea.
³Department of Pathology, Inje University College of Medicine, Busan, Korea.
⁴Department of Pathology, Dong-A University College of Medicine, Busan, Korea. msroh@dau.ac.kr

3,699 Views
18 Download
6 Crossref
7 Scopus

Full Article

Download PDF

Abstract

BACKGROUND
Although the grade of pulmonary carcinoid tumor is routinely reported in pathology practice, there is a paucity of data on the level of agreement between pathologists.
METHODS
Data for 30 cases of surgically resected pulmonary tumors diagnosed as carcinoid tumors (19 typical carcinoids [TCs] and 11 atypical carcinoids [ACs]) were retrieved from four university hospitals. These cases were independently evaluated by five pathologists and were classified according to the 2004 World Health Organization (WHO) classification. Agreement was regarded as "unanimous" if all five pathologists agreed, and as a "majority" if four agreed. The kappa statistic was calculated to measure the degree of agreement between pathologists.
RESULTS
Unanimous agreement was achieved for 50.0% and a majority agreement for 83.3% of the 30 cases. The range of the kappa values extended from 0.37 to 0.89. After a consensus meeting, there was disagreement between the original diagnosis by each institute and the consensus diagnosis by the five pathologists for 40.0% of the 30 cases. Based on the consensus diagnosis, the agreement was greater for TCs than that for ACs.
CONCLUSIONS
Discriminating carcinoid tumors is subject to interobserver variability. This study indicates that there is a need for more careful standardization and application of diagnostic criteria for making the diagnosis of pulmonary carcinoid tumor.

Keywords: Lung;Carcinoid tumor;Observer variation;

Figure & Data

References

Citations

Citations to this article as recorded by

Limited additive value of the Ki‐67 proliferative index on patient survival in World Health Organization‐classified pulmonary carcinoids
Dorian R A Swarts, Martina Rudelius, Sandra M H Claessen, Jack P Cleutjens, Stefan Seidl, Marco Volante, Frans C S Ramaekers, Ernst J M Speel
Histopathology.2017; 70(3): 412. CrossRef
Interobserver Variability for the WHO Classification of Pulmonary Carcinoids
Dorian R.A. Swarts, Robert-Jan van Suylen, Michael A. den Bakker, Matthijs F.M. van Oosterhout, Frederik B.J.M. Thunnissen, Marco Volante, Anne-Marie C. Dingemans, Marc R.M. Scheltinga, Gerben P. Bootsma, Harry M.M. Pouwels, Ben E.E.M. van den Borne, Fran
American Journal of Surgical Pathology.2014; 38(10): 1429. CrossRef
Lung parenchymal invasion in pulmonary carcinoid tumor: An important histologic feature suggesting the diagnosis of atypical carcinoid and poor prognosis
Sang Yun Ha, Jae Jun Lee, Junhun Cho, Jiyeon Hyeon, Joungho Han, Hong Kwan Kim
Lung Cancer.2013; 80(2): 146. CrossRef
CD44 and OTP Are Strong Prognostic Markers for Pulmonary Carcinoids
Dorian R.A. Swarts, Mieke E.R. Henfling, Leander Van Neste, Robert-Jan van Suylen, Anne-Marie C. Dingemans, Winand N.M. Dinjens, Annick Haesevoets, Martina Rudelius, Erik Thunnissen, Marco Volante, Wim Van Criekinge, Manon van Engeland, Frans C.S. Ramaeke
Clinical Cancer Research.2013; 19(8): 2197. CrossRef
Altered expression of microRNA miR‐21, miR‐155, and let‐7a and their roles in pulmonary neuroendocrine tumors
Hyoun Wook Lee, Eun Hee Lee, Seung Yeon Ha, Chang Hun Lee, Hee Kyung Chang, Sunhee Chang, Kun Young Kwon, Il Seon Hwang, Mee Sook Roh, Jeong Wook Seo
Pathology International.2012; 62(9): 583. CrossRef
Differential expression of forkhead box M1 and its downstream cyclin‐dependent kinase inhibitors p27kip1 and p21waf1/cip1 in the diagnosis of pulmonary neuroendocrine tumours
Seung Yeon Ha, Chang Hun Lee, Hee Kyung Chang, Sunhee Chang, Kun Young Kwon, Eun Hee Lee, Mee Sook Roh, Boram Seo
Histopathology.2012; 60(5): 731. CrossRef

Cited

Related articles